Friday, June 12, 2009

Ritual vs Superstition

Yesterday, I was having a discussion on the existence of rituals with a friend of mine.

Every community follows certain rituals and most people do not know why they follow. The tragedy is that they do not even try to seek answers or explanations or rationale behind them following those rituals...and sometimes superstitions!

In fact, etymologically, rationale is what distinguishes a ritual from a superstition. If the practice is backed by logic and is rational then you call it a ritual else a superstition. But then, rationality itself is something very abstract and subjective, so, I would not like to enter that territory of discussion.



I simply call it a belief system. And for most souls, either convenience or fear is the driving force behind their belief system. So, rationality and logic takes a back seat when people start following things based on what they've seen their ancestors doing and their priests preaching, without introspecting or questioning.

Here's a nice and apt story about how we start following certain rituals...GURU AND THE CAT

When the guru sat down to worship each evening the ashram cat would get in the way and distract the worshipers. So he ordered that the cat be tied up during evening worship.

Long after the guru died, the cat continued to be tied during the evening worship. And when the cat eventually died, another cat was brought to the ashram so that it could be duly tied during evening worship.

Centuries later learned treatises were written by the guru's disciples on the essential role of the tied cat in all properly conducted evening worship.

So, what do we call it - a ritual or a superstition? And where and how do we strike the right balance (as the picture depicts)?

4 comments:

Yogesh Goel said...

jo chal raha hai who chalta ja raha hai...ha the followers r getting lesser by the day until one day all will start a new...

baaki to ram hi raakhe..
lol...

tke cre
b well...
Yogesh
ygoel.com

Ankit said...

nice post!!

but it is very imp to define rituals.. i guess it includes superstition...rationality is a diff concept which may or may not be a part of ritual, as u said fear or convenience do not need any rational... but nevertheless a nice subject to ponder upon happy blogging :)

Yogesh Goel said...

@VT - Vivek

ha bhai..
kiya to hai...
trying one out of two options..

yogeshgoel.com
ygoel.com

i guess the second one seems short and good...

what do u say...

yogeshgoel.com had some sync problems with blogger as registration me kuch lafda ho gaya tha...

whereas ygoel.com will be syncd soon...the sync phase is going on...

ur opinion is highly wanted...

tke cre
b well..

Yogesh

A said...

good one!